Bobkat
1979 x1/9
I agree with the others, any proprietary designs that you wish to develop yourself (e.g. engine swap kit) should be protected (i.e. not openly shared). However the standard Fiat X1/9 engine bay is a different situation. It is not proprietary to any of us. Fiat may have restrictions on copying it, but that's not what we're talking about. I understand the scanning equipment was expensive, and your time to do the scanning has value. But those are costs that you are undertaking as part of your development project. So sharing the basic dimensions/scan data for the stock engine bay would not impact that. Your choice obviously but I really don't get the point, as it would not have any relation to anything you develop to put in the bay. Just my view on it, and to be clear I have no interest in any of the data. If I've misunderstood something here please correct me. Great project either way.
Yes I think there is a bit of confusion here. I have said that I would make any scan mesh data available. A scan is just a base to start working over. Think of it as the scan is just like a picture you want to trace. You would lay trace paper over a picture and trace what you want. You would not trace every tiny detail of a picture down to blades of grass, just what you want. I will not reverse engineer(trace) every inch of the engine bay or motors, I will only convert to CAD (trace) the points I am interested in. In my case the mount points; dog bone, lower mount bar holes on the frame, and the front motor mount, on the frame. I only need to locate these holes in a 3D space, I don't need to reverse engineer the entire bay for that.
I will do the same to the 07k Motor/trans and use the two scans to help position it in the bay. I will design the mounts between the holes on both ends so the only CAD files will be the mount themselves.