Frankly Brett... I'd be more...
... concerned if:
1. It functioned properly and ducted the air up and through the radiator and then...
2. Whether or not YOU like it. Who cares about someone else's "opinion".
As for me... it "appears" it would function properly, only a test drive and recording operating temps would tell for sure. Remove it completely for a comparison and if you have a stocker, install it also for a trial.
As for my "opinion", if it should matter, it looks "right" for the car... and I like it.