Dr.Auto
Matthew Walsh
Well the last wreak I was in the lady that hit me watched her car burn to the ground....well almost to the ground before the fire truck showed up. The fender/hood tweaked in such a way that one of the body panels shorted across the posative and negative battery posts. And I guess the hygregen fumes (a by product of hyrdacloric acid) that a lead acid battery can emit are combustable. enough to blow the top off the battery and somehow in the mix the fuel lines not more than a foot away made of plastic leaked fuel and caught on fire. Or maybe it was a reversal of what I'm saying i don't know.... I just know there was fire and the battery blew up and there were arc marks on the hood area from the battery posts.One last point. I've never seen a battery explode due to accident damage. Saw one flashover when a jump-starter was connected to the electrode posts once on a cracked battery but that just blew out the safety bung and showered everyone with acid.
regardless I saw a tech charging a battery and decided to loosen the battery terminal at the same time....acidentially arcing between the two posts igniting the hydragen fumes and thankfully no more than that because he was not wearing safety glasses. So lead acid batteries in them selves can be a flamable hazard.
I would say that perhaps it's been quite some time since you have worked on a modern car. At least here in America. Where EVERYTHING literally has in tank fuel pumps with wires going to them with system voltage on them. And although they are brushless pumps the wiring including the connectors are still submerged in fuel. Every single chevy truck since the early 90's are produced like this to this day. Every subaru, toyota, honda, kia, ford, dodge, that I have ever had to work on in the last 14 years as a professional automotive technitian has a fuel system like this. And modern fuel systems (within the last 5 years) have not changed much. they are all plastic tanks now with plastic fuel lines. With the pump in tank and a returnless fuel system meaning the regulator and return line from regulator are part of the fuel pump sender assembly in the tank and one fuel line goes through a filter and all the way to the engine providing in excess of 50psi.Another point is this, which immersed fuel pump are you refering to? Most cars designers affix the fuel pump to the engine block (front engine installs) with the fuel tank between or in front of, the rear wheels for protection. It's more efficient to pull a column of fuel along a fuel line to where it's needed that to try and push that fuel from the back of the vehicle forwards. Pumping frictional losses work that way.
But before this thread gets hi jacked I'm going to shut up and go on with life.
I agree that anything arcing a battery is not good.... in the presence of a fuel source weather it be a fuel tank, fuel lines, or fuel rail. Arcing a battery is also not good for a lead acid battery as if there is enough hydrogen fumes built up they will ignite. And although any arc (from battery voltage or just friction from a wreak) caused for any reason is an ignition source for any type of combustable weather it be gasoline, hydrogen fumes, or a very strong mixture of window washer fluid.
And I guess I'm just saying that I would focus on containing the battery in it's own enclosure to maintain a safety standard. The battery to me is the problem.... even though in the car world there are main power wires and fuel lines strung in somewhat close proximity of each other including power wires for the fuel pump.
But I think you're point here is if something were to arc the battery or any of it's wiring in the presence of a fuel leak it would be bad.
And my point is that a starter wire can arc just as easily and ignite a fuel leak in the engine bay vs the battery arcing and blowing up the fuel tank if it were leaking.... in both scenrios the fuel tank can still blow up.
This is why I prefer a gel style battery with good protection for the terminals and then it doesn't matter.