The only change is the short wire you had previously connected from (bat) terminal on alt to #2 terminal on alt is now a wire all the way to the starter? If that is so, then the wire you made previously (shown in your pic below) must have had no continuity - there is no other explanation. Did you check the wire with your multimeter for continuity?
Did you also check the existing wire from starter to alt for continuity?
What's difference between running the #2 wire to the alt's own lug, the starter or the battery, they are all connected right to each other anyway, no? I agree with Hussein, your little wire must have bad connections since the above path is all the same circuit.
How does your charge light still work if #1 wire isn't connected anymore?
Yup, both wires check out fine. I don't get it either.
I got all excited over 14.5v though
After seeing the 14.5v drop to 14v, I began researching this wiring more and came across this (I have the 12SI alt):
http://bob_skelly.home.comcast.net/~bob_skelly/alternator_conversion/wiring_alternator1.html
It suggests that:
[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif][FONT="]"It is better to run the sense wire away from the alternator and over to the power terminal post near the battery. This will ensure that the system voltage is properly maintained."[/FONT]
[/FONT]
So, I have decided not to jumper #2 to the BAT on the alternator but instead, run 8ga wire to the terminal "junction" in the fuse box. Doing so, I get 14.6v at the battery. At the same time, I've ripped out the brown wire and brown wire mod, replacing those 2 wires with a single 4ga wire.
Now the real test is to take the charge indicator bulb out of its socket and see if it still charges, I don't think we ever settled that debate did we?
It seemed to me above that your number 1 wasn't wired right because it wasn't shown in the pic... but apparently the problem was your battery wasn't connected through the starter. Is that correct?
IF you have short-wired the alternator and are getting 14.4 at the alternator but 14 at the battery, you probably need to clean connectors somewhere (starter) or terminals, that's a lot of loss for a short distance.
After seeing the 14.5v drop to 14v, I began researching this wiring more and came across this (I have the 12SI alt):
http://bob_skelly.home.comcast.net/~bob_skelly/alternator_conversion/wiring_alternator1.html
It suggests that:
[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif][FONT="]"It is better to run the sense wire away from the alternator and over to the power terminal post near the battery. This will ensure that the system voltage is properly maintained."
[/FONT][/FONT]
So, I have decided not to jumper #2 to the BAT on the alternator but instead, run 8ga wire to the terminal "junction" in the fuse box. Doing so, I get 14.6v at the battery. At the same time, I've ripped out the brown wire and brown wire mod, replacing those 2 wires with a single 4ga wire.